Oh, Robert Redford! I admire you casting Mary Tyler Moore in this, for a couple reasons. The main one being half the time she is absolutely right for this role, then the other half she is so absolutely wrong. I think it’s rare that Mary Tyler Moore ever comes off as anything but adorable, even at the age 50 when she filmed this.
I would have preferred an actress that I had an easier time hating, yet I think someone colder would have made the mother in the story a total villain, which would have been a wrong direction to take this film in. I also think (in a completely non-professional opinion) that survivor’s guilt is a pretty natural human emotion, and it’s really hard to identify with someone who doesn’t feel it in the least, like Moore’s character.
That being said, pretty much everyone in this film did a phenomenal job. I expected being impressed with Timothy Hutton since he did win an Oscar for this role, but I didn’t expect to be so impressed with Donald Sutherland, who completely nails the role of a husband trying to keep his family together while hiding the fact that he’s not in love with his wife anymore. Judd Hirsch is also really good, but he’s always good.
However, it is interesting to note that Hutton carries the majority of the film, but received his numerous accolades as a supporting actor. I was also surprised to see Adam Baldwin. Actually, at first I said “oh no, that can’t be him” but apparently he’s not as young as I thought. Oh Jayne!
3 down, 97 to go.
It’s official: I’m in a Clint Eastwood phase in my life. I enjoyed most everything about
It’s incredibly hard to watch